Skip to content

Concrete & Confined Concrete

materials-concreteApplies to create / edit / troubleshoot~860 tokens

The desktop AI reads from the same knowledge base — this page is its English edition. When the AI cites 📖 guide · materials-concrete in a conversation, it refers to this entry.

In One Sentence

Concrete materials raise two questions that must be answered: whether to include the tension branch (flexural members must have it), and whether to split cover from core concrete (any member with stirrups must be split). Get either wrong and the results will be wrong in ways you can’t see.

Choosing Among the Four Models

Model Compression branch Tension branch When to use
Concrete01 Polyline (Karsan-Jirsa unloading) None Compression-only members: columns under axial load, core concrete
Concrete02 Polyline + unloading stiffness degradation Linear softening Flexural members (beams, slabs)—the most common choice
Concrete04 Smooth Popovics curve Exponential softening When smooth curves and high accuracy under cyclic loading are needed
Concrete07 Chang-Mander Yes When a full confinement model and more realistic hysteresis are needed

Selection rule of thumb: flexure → Concrete02; pure compression → Concrete01 works, but using 02 uniformly is recommended; cyclic + accuracy → Concrete04.

Core Parameters

Parameter Meaning C30 reference value Unit
f′c Peak compressive stress (negative) −20.1 (fck) MPa = kN/mm²
εc0 Strain at peak stress −0.002 Dimensionless
f′cu Residual compressive stress (negative) about −4 (≈ 0.2 f′c) MPa
εu Ultimate compressive strain −0.0033 Dimensionless
ft Tensile strength (positive) 2.01 (ftk) MPa
Ets Tension-softening stiffness ft/εtu, typically on the order of E/10 MPa
λ Unloading stiffness ratio 0.1–0.5 Dimensionless
Ec Elastic modulus (only needed for Concrete04) 30 000 (= 30 kN/mm²) MPa

Mind the signs: compression is negative, tension is positive—this is the OpenSees convention. Reversed signs will not raise an error, but the concrete becomes a strange material that “yields in tension”; the solve still runs and the results are completely wrong.

The Three Questions You Must Answer

Question 1: Which strength value to use

GB 50010 defines three strengths—the constitutive model takes the second one:

Symbol Name C30 value Used for
fcu,k Characteristic cube compressive strength 30 Grade naming only
fck Characteristic prism compressive strength 20.1 Peak stress of the constitutive model
fc Design compressive strength 14.3 Capacity design, not a constitutive parameter

Entering 30 overestimates capacity by about 50%; entering 14.3 underestimates it by about 30%. Only 20.1 is correct.

Question 2: Whether to include the tension branch

Concrete’s tensile strength is only about 1/10 of its compressive strength, so many people omit it. But a flexural member’s stiffness, cracking load, and crack spacing all depend on the tension branch.

  • Omitting the tension branch → stiffness suddenly drops to zero after cracking → deflections too large, natural frequencies too low
  • Entering Ets too stiff → the concrete “holds on” in tension → cracking load overestimated

How to gauge Ets: the tension-softening branch drops from ft to 0 over a strain interval usually taken as εtu ≈ 0.001 (about 10 times the cracking strain), so Ets ≈ ft/0.001 = 2010 MPa (C30). Entering Ec (30000) is 15 times too stiff.

Question 3: Whether to split cover from core

In columns and piers with stirrups, the core concrete is confined: both strength and ultimate strain increase. Filling the whole section with one set of parameters is a common mistake.

The Mander confined concrete model (1988, public literature, standard in structural engineering):

f′cc = f′c · [−1.254 + 2.254·√(1 + 7.94·f′l/f′c) − 2·f′l/f′c]
εcc = εc0 · [1 + 5·(f′cc/f′c − 1)]

where f′l is the effective lateral confining stress; for rectangular stirrups estimate it with (take the smaller of the x and y directions):

f′l = ke · ρs · fyh / 2 (simplified form; ke is the effectiveness factor, typically 0.5–0.8)

Zoning practice (fiber section):

Zone Material Parameters
Cover (outside stirrups) Unconfined concrete f′c = fck, εu = 0.0033
Core (inside stirrups) Confined concrete f′cc increased per the formula above, εcc increased accordingly

Typical magnitudes: for a column with 1% volumetric stirrup ratio and fyh = 300, f′l ≈ 1.5 MPa, f′cc/f′c ≈ 1.25–1.4, εcc ≈ 0.004–0.006. That is, core strength increases 25–40% and peak strain increases 2–3 times—a difference that is very visible in the descending branch of a Pushover curve.

Consequence of not zoning: column ductility is underestimated, plastic hinge length cannot be computed reliably, and the Pushover descending branch appears too early.

Five High-Frequency Errors

Error 1: Entering the cube strength

Entering 30 (fcu,k) instead of 20.1 (fck). Capacity is overestimated by 50%, and every result that depends on concrete strength runs high.

Error 2: Using Concrete01 for flexural members

Concrete01 has no tension branch, so beam stiffness jumps abruptly after cracking. Beams and slabs must use Concrete02 or Concrete04.

Error 3: Reversed signs

Entering f′c as +20.1. The concrete becomes a tension-only material; the solve runs but all results are wrong. Compression negative, tension positive.

Error 4: One parameter set for the whole section

Stirrups present but no core/cover split. Ductility underestimated, Pushover descending branch too early.

Error 5: Entering Ets as Ec

Tension-softening stiffness entered as 30000 (= Ec). Concrete’s tensile stiffness is 15 times too large, the cracking load is overestimated, and beam deflections run small—it looks like “good structural performance” but it’s simply wrong.

Criteria: Four Consistency Checks

  1. ft/f′c should fall in 0.08–0.12 (C30: 2.01/20.1 = 0.10). Outside that range means the wrong strength value
  2. Ec/f′c should fall in 1000–1500 (C30: 30000/20.1 = 1493). Getting 100 000 means the units are wrong
  3. εc0 should be between 0.0018 and 0.0025. Entering 0.02 is off by an order of magnitude
  4. f′cc/f′c for confined concrete should be between 1.15 and 1.5. Above 2 means the stirrup ratio or fyh was entered wrong

The calculation report prints f′c, ft, εc0, and εu for every concrete material, along with whether it is flagged as confined concrete—that flag affects how reviewers read your ductility conclusions.

concreteconfinementMandertension softeningpeak straincover